Exploring Glulam and Solid Timber for Timber Framing

‍

Timber framing offers a timeless, natural beauty for both residential and commercial builds. Within this method of construction, two materials stand out as the preferred option among builders and architects: glulam (glue-laminated timber) and heavy timber.

Both are exceptional choices, bringing unique strengths, sustainability profiles, and visual character to a project. Whether you’re a builder, architect, or homeowner, understanding these differences will help you select the right material for your vision.

‍

Strength and Structural Performance: Glulam Beams vs Solid Timber Beams

‍

Glulam Beams:

Glulam beams are engineered by laminating multiple layers of wood together with strong adhesives.  This process distributes natural imperfections and enables the creation of beams with impressive load-bearing capacity and dimensional stability. Glulam is especially valued for its ability to span long distances and form curves or custom shapes, making it a powerful tool for innovative architectural designs.

‍

• High Load-Bearing Capacity: Glulam beams are engineered to deliver impressive strength. According to the Engineered Wood Association, Douglas fir glulam beams can achieve a bending strength rating of up to 2,400 psi and a modulus of elasticity up to 1.8 million psi. This allows glulam to efficiently support heavy loads and long spans, making it ideal for large open spaces and complex architectural forms.

• Dimensional Stability: The laminated construction of glulam minimizes natural movement. Glulam beams are made from kiln-dried (KD) material and experience significantly less warping and shrinking compared to solid timber. For example, an 8.75-inch-wide glulam beam typically undergoes less than a quarter-inch width change as it adjusts to indoor humidity. This stability results from the way multiple layers are bonded together, distributing stresses and reducing the impact of wood’s natural tendencies.

‍

Solid Timber Beams:

Solid timber beams are milled from a single piece of wood and form the essential structural elements of classic timber framing. Douglas fir in particular is renowned for its high strength-to-weight ratio and straight, tight grain, making it a preferred choice for demanding structural roles in both residential and commercial projects.

‍

• Natural Strength: Dried Douglas fir timbers offer impressive structural performance, with bending strengths up to 12,400 psi and compression strengths parallel to grain up to 7,000 psi. These values make Douglas fir a great material choice for beams, posts, and trusses that bear significant loads and span wide distances.
• Time-Tested Reliability: The longevity and reliability of heavy timber framing depend on both the inherent quality of Douglas fir and skilled joinery. Careful seasoning and expert craftsmanship play an important role in enhancing the longevity and integrity of timber frames over time. Traditional mortise and tenon joinery distribute loads efficiently and has enabled timber structures to endure for centuries.

‍

‍

Visual Appeal in Architectural Design

‍

Glulam: Consistency, Versatility, and Modern Elegance

‍

• Smooth, Consistent Appearance: Glulam offers a uniform surface with minimal knots, ideal for contemporary or minimalist projects.
• Design Flexibility: The ability to fabricate long spans, curves, and custom shapes supports bold architectural statements.
• Stable Over Time: Glulam’s engineered nature means it is less likely to develop large cracks or twists, retaining a consistent appearance over time.

‍

vs Solid Timber: Authenticity, Character, and Timeless Warmth

‍

• Natural Variation: Each beam features unique grain patterns and knots, giving every project a distinct and authentic character - whether the design is sleek and minimal or warm and textured.
• Design Flexibility: Solid timber beams can be finished in a variety of ways to suit different architectural styles. Smooth, planed (S4S) timbers offer a clean, contemporary look ideal for modern spaces, while rough-sawn finishes create a more rustic or traditional aesthetic.
• Organic Character: The inherent warmth and texture of solid timber bring a timeless quality to any space, complementing both modern and classic interiors with natural elegance.

‍

Sustainability and Environmental Impact

‍

Glulam:

Glulam makes efficient use of smaller, fast-growing trees and lower-grade timber, maximizing resource use and minimizing waste. It is typically produced from sustainably managed forests and has a low carbon footprint compared to steel or concrete. The manufacturing process allows for offcuts to be repurposed, furthering sustainability efforts.

‍

Solid Timber:

Solid timber, when sourced responsibly, is a renewable and environmentally friendly choice. Many suppliers - including Canadian TImberframes - prioritize sustainable forestry practices, sourcing their timber from ethically managed forest stands. Solid timber’s longevity and ability to be reclaimed or repurposed at the end of its life cycle further contribute to its green profile.

‍

Blending Glulam and Solid Timber: The Best of Both Worlds

‍

Many projects benefit from combining both materials-using glulam for structural elements that demand long spans or curves, and solid timber for visible features where exposed timber is desired. This approach allows for both architectural flexibility and the timeless appeal of timber.

‍

Practical Considerations

‍

• Structural Performance: Glulam’s engineered strength and stability make it ideal for beams, arches, and other elements that need to span large distances or support complex loads. Solid timber remains a reliable and robust choice for posts, trusses, and decorative framing, especially where the unique grain and texture of wood are showcased.
• Design Flexibility: Using both materials allows architects and builders to achieve ambitious designs-combining glulam’s ability to form sweeping curves and open spaces with the timeless appeal of solid timber in visible or tactile areas.
• Cost: Glulam can be cost-effective for larger spans or custom shapes but can become less cost-effective when dealing with many small pieces, while solid timber remains a versatile and competitive choice for most timber framing applications.

‍

Choosing the Right Material Mix for Your Timber Frame Project

‍

Both glulam and solid timber are outstanding choices for timber framing. The decision often comes down to your design vision, structural requirements, and personal preference for visual character.

‍

• Use glulam where you need long, uninterrupted spans, curves, or highly consistent engineered performance.
• Use solid timber for areas where natural wood character, tactile appeal, or traditional joinery are priorities.

‍

By thoughtfully blending glulam and solid timber, you can create structures that are not only strong and efficient but also visually striking and full of character. This flexible approach allows you to achieve both innovative design and timeless warmth.